I have loved this recording for over 40 years. I own the original vinyl LP. I was thrilled when this became available on CD. I was afraid that some of the richness and velvety tone would be lost in the transition to CD, but it sounds fine. (Almost as good as vinyl.) This is a superb rendition of the Rhapsody. Rubinstein's interpretation is romantic and masculine; the music lives and breathes. Rubinstein's version of de Falla's "Nights in the Gardens of Spain" is lighter, more elegant and exotic. There might be better versions of the de Falla piece out there, but for me, this version of the "Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini" has never been surpassed. And as I said, the sound on this CD is faithful to the original LP, and while not quite as full and nuanced as the original, it is still fine enough not to distract me when I listen to the CD. I highly recommend this CD.--R. Rubin Listen to samples
22.3.10
RACHMANINOV: CONCERTO NO.2/RHAPSODY ON A THEME OF PAGANINI
This is one of the finest performance and recording of these pieces available. Gary Graffman shows his brilliant talent in these interpretations of Rachmaninoff. Far too many think that speed is critical in performing specific passages when in fact patience is required. One may have the skill to play all the notes but lack the talent to perform the music. Graffman performs with nuance and subtlety as well as skill and decision in bringing the souls of these pieces to life. Highly recommended. (You'll throw your other recordings away after hearing this!)--Rob Smout
RHAPSODY ON A THEME OF PAGANINI, OPUS 43
Sergey Rachmaninov
(1873-1943)
The Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini, composed in 1934, is one of Rachmaninov’s most popular works. The clear shape of the theme, from Paganini’s vilolin Caprice in A minor, heip Rachmaninov to control procedures which elsewhere had often become rather ramblingly improvisatory. The result is a taut structure in which the variations on the theme can roughly be divided into three sections, as Geoffery Norris and other writers have pointed out variations 1-10 (for the most part quick); 11-18 (predominantly slow); and 19-24 (lively throughout). These sections coincide loosely with the three movements of a concerto. The basic outline of the theme in the first variation precedes the theme itself. Rachmaninov has perceived that it bears a resemblance to the Dies Irae, which dominates variations 7-10 and plays an important role later as well. The florid variation 11, with its cadenza-like passages, effects a modulation from the key hitherto largely employed. A minor to D minor for the next two variations, then to F major and, in variation 18 (the culmination of the middle section), to D flat major for one of the most delectably lyrical of all Rachmaninov’s melodies, ingeniously based on a free inversion of Paganini’s theme. From variation 19 (again in A minor) the rhythmic impetus and tempo gradually increase until the final, twenty-fourth variation, in which the Dies Irae is portentously restated in the course of a dramatic peroration, capped by a whimsically soft snippet of the theme.
It is because this series of variations is constructed with such exquisite care, and encapsulates such a wide variety of moods and of moods and of melodies cleverly derived from Paganini’s original, that it is generally considered to be Rachmaninov’s greatest concerted work. And it is no mean feat to have matched the achievement of earlier composers who wrote variations on the same theme, most notably Brahms.
(1873-1943)
The Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini, composed in 1934, is one of Rachmaninov’s most popular works. The clear shape of the theme, from Paganini’s vilolin Caprice in A minor, heip Rachmaninov to control procedures which elsewhere had often become rather ramblingly improvisatory. The result is a taut structure in which the variations on the theme can roughly be divided into three sections, as Geoffery Norris and other writers have pointed out variations 1-10 (for the most part quick); 11-18 (predominantly slow); and 19-24 (lively throughout). These sections coincide loosely with the three movements of a concerto. The basic outline of the theme in the first variation precedes the theme itself. Rachmaninov has perceived that it bears a resemblance to the Dies Irae, which dominates variations 7-10 and plays an important role later as well. The florid variation 11, with its cadenza-like passages, effects a modulation from the key hitherto largely employed. A minor to D minor for the next two variations, then to F major and, in variation 18 (the culmination of the middle section), to D flat major for one of the most delectably lyrical of all Rachmaninov’s melodies, ingeniously based on a free inversion of Paganini’s theme. From variation 19 (again in A minor) the rhythmic impetus and tempo gradually increase until the final, twenty-fourth variation, in which the Dies Irae is portentously restated in the course of a dramatic peroration, capped by a whimsically soft snippet of the theme.
It is because this series of variations is constructed with such exquisite care, and encapsulates such a wide variety of moods and of moods and of melodies cleverly derived from Paganini’s original, that it is generally considered to be Rachmaninov’s greatest concerted work. And it is no mean feat to have matched the achievement of earlier composers who wrote variations on the same theme, most notably Brahms.
14.3.10
Prokofiev: Romeo and Juliet
This is without doubt one of the best CDs I own, and surely the best contemporary one. The orchestra performs so cleanly and magically that you don't even realize that there are instruments playing the melodies, just a story being told. (which is the point, you're not listening to music, but rather a story) I think Prokofiev captured the spirit of the play really, really well; themes such as the shrill highs and unsettling lows of Tybalt Recognizes Romeo really give me the chills and develop the characters. Other highlights include the Dance of the Knights, Romeo Resolves to Avenge Mercutio (the buildup after the violent repeating percussion halfway through the track is enchantingly Prokofiev-esque--the themes building upon one another, really making the listener feel for him/herself the grief and anger), and the pretty but faintly creepy and forboding Morning Serenade. The Epilogue, luckily, tops even these, and you really feel Romeo's despair as he dances with lifeless Juliet. This is one of those CDs that I thought mediocre upon first listening, but upon second and third I fell in love. Beautiful beyond words. Now I want to see the ballet! --Tyler Kerce "russophile" Listen to samples
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)